When Yugi Mutou and Katsuya Jonouchi collected their Duel Disks at the RPG Hobby Trading Cards shop in advent of the Battle City tournament, the card shop manager noticed Jonouchi had a rare valuable card, "Red-Eyes Black Dragon". He alerted the Rare Hunters, leading them to target Jonouchi that night. After one of them defeated Jonouchi in a Duel, he and his associates assaulted Jonouchi and took his "Red-Eyes" card.
The next day, during the Battle City tournament, Dark Yugi overheard a confrontation between Jonouchi and the Rare Hunter, who had defeated him. Disgusted by people who steal others' sentimental cards, Dark Yugi challenged the Rare Hunter to a Duel, against the advice of Jonouchi. Jonouchi tried to warn Dark Yugi of the hunter's strategy, but Dark Yugi refused to accept an unfair advantage.
1st turn: Dark Yugi
2nd turn: Rare Hunter
The hunter drew "Graceful Charity" and activated it, drawing three cards and discarding two. His hand then contained "Right Arm of the Forbidden One", "Right Leg of the Forbidden One", "Left Arm of the Forbidden One", "Barrierroid Garman".
Dark Yugi suspected the Rare Hunter was a "turtle"-style player, whose defenses he would need to get through. The hunter was happy to have Dark Yugi focus on his monsters, while he gathered the cards that he needed.
3rd turn: Dark Yugi
Dark Yugi Summoned "Baphomet" and activated his face-down "Polymerization", fusing "Baphomet" with "Gazelle" to Summon "Chimera the Flying Mythical Beast". According to the Super Expert Rules, monsters cannot attack the same turn they are fused, so he ended his turn.
4th turn: Rare Hunter
The Rare Hunter activated another "Graceful Charity", with "Right Arm of the Forbidden One" and "Exodia the Forbidden One" among the cards he drew. He cursed the repetition of the "Right Arm", but was relieved to be just one card short of completing "Exodia". Using his specialized contact lenses on the specially inked counterfeit cards, he could see that the final piece, "Left Arm of the Forbidden One" was on top of his Deck.
5th turn: Dark Yugi
Dark Yugi grew suspicious of the hunter's hand exchanges and disinterest in attacking and deduced that he must be planning on winning with "Exodia". He called the hunter out on his plan and vowed to crush "Exodia" with the card in his hand.
Dark Yugi worried about playing "Chain Destruction" this turn, as it would prevent him from Summoning another monster, but fearing the Rare Hunter had already gathered most of the pieces of "Exodia", decided to go for and played it.
6th turn: Rare Hunter
As the Rare Hunter was about to draw his card, Dark Yugi activated "Lightforce Sword", forcing one card from the hunter's hand, "Right Arm of the Forbidden One" onto the field. He then activated "Chain Destruction" to destroy it and all further copies in the Hunter's hand and Deck.
With no copies of the "Right Arm" left, the Rare Hunter was left unable to gather a complete set of the five pieces. Without "Exodia", Dark Yugi declared that the hunter had no way to win. The hunter admitted he had lost, but was shocked that his Deck could be defeated.
The following cards from each players' Decks were shown.
- ↑ Yu-Gi-Oh! Duelist Duel 92: "Rare Hunters!"
- ↑ 2.0 2.1 Yu-Gi-Oh! Duelist Duel 93: "Battle City Begins!"
- ↑ 3.0 3.1 3.2 3.3 3.4 3.5 3.6 3.7 3.8 3.9 Yu-Gi-Oh! Duelist Duel 94: "Duel of Vengeance!"
- ↑ 4.0 4.1 4.2 4.3 4.4 Yu-Gi-Oh! Duelist Duel 95: "To Destroy a Deck"
- ↑ 5.0 5.1 Yu-Gi-Oh! Duelist Duel 96: "Millennium Battle"