User talk:Resk/DFF

=DFF Trials= Trial Archives

SquirtleHero - 3rd Try - Testers are Ace, SM10, and Lappy - Trial 7
Been too long. Denied. -- - Dark Ace SP ( Talk )  00:25, March 10, 2012 (UTC)
 * Apparently her, computer broke. Consider this Trial Pending.

-- - Dark Ace SP ( Talk )  23:31, March 10, 2012 (UTC)


 * Wow! Not bad, she's actually improved quite a bit. Personally, I find the Blackwings odd, I can kinda see Zephyros working, but if she wanted Chaos, she could have easily put in a Tour Guide Trio to bring out Sangan. I don't think Gorz the Emissary of Darkness is really needed, and 2 Chaos Sorc. is a bit too much. Where is Shining Angel to toolbox? Maybe a few Break! Draw! and 1-2 PoD? -- - Dark Ace SP ( Talk )  20:47, March 11, 2012 (UTC)

I hate to say that I'm disappointed, but I'm disappointed. It's easy to see the theory behind the deck, and it's a great theory. Good enough that for the first time, I actually chose to try out a trial deck.

And that is where the disappointment comes from. As good as it looks (minus the Ishzarks) it simply does not work. Chaos Zone does not happen. I wish that Mind Control and the third Alchemist had been played instead of Ishzarks. It's madness to play triple Valley and no Mind Control. I also would have liked to see Tour Guides in order to make Leviair and some Call of the Haunteds.

I hate to fail her a third time, but I can't say yes. Lappyzard (talk • contribs) 01:46, March 12, 2012 (UTC)


 * D.D. Warrior Lady would have been better than Ishzark. -- - Dark Ace SP ( Talk )  20:10, March 12, 2012 (UTC)

I must say, the deck looks very good. Mine is actually pretty similar in quite a few areas. The only things I noticed are BLS with 5 DARKS that are unreliable to get in the Grave easily, but that's not a major problem. Although maybe unneeded, I actually liked the idea of Unknown Synchron to give a little more Synchro power to the deck. 3 Kid seems a bit excessive, but it is an exceptionally good card in this format and gives another Lv 4 target for Ammonite. I personally run 2 Alien Telepaths instead to give some S/T destruction. 1-2 more Planet Pollutant would have been nice because it's an awesome card, but, once again, nothing major. She even ran the correct number of Alien Overlords, which is often overkilled at 3. She's come a long way overall, the potential is definitely there, and I'm gonna have to say yes, especially just looking at my deck. Overall, the only deck that has a couple of more major issues is the Crane deck, but Chaos Zone doesn't work with any deck, unless the deck is built specifically around it. Even then, it doesn't always work like you'd expect it to. xD Synchro Maniac10 (talk • contribs) 15:06, March 29, 2012 (UTC)

User:AEtherchild - Testers are Lappy, Ace,and Wolf - Trial 14 - Passed
Ace's Comments:
 * Run Torrential at 2.
 * Why user Lumenize when you can use Honest?
 * The use of Dragonic Tactics was pretty interesting.
 * Missing Hieroglyph Dragon - Dragon Geib.
 * I think the idea was to tribute 2 Hieroglyph(s) with Dragonic Tactics for GEPD and 2 Seal of the God Dragon. Then it's theoretically possible to summon Neo Galaxy-Eyes Photon Dragon. However, if he really wanted that, Geib would have been perfect, he only takes up a single Normal Summon, compared to the others that need to be either Tribute Summoned or Special Summoned.
 * I'll need to play with it to see how it runs. -- - Dark Ace SP ( Talk )  18:23, March 11, 2012 (UTC)


 * I think he's good overall guys. Plus, we really need more active members and he dose have skill. A few bumps here and there, but overall good. -- - Dark Ace SP  ( Talk )  17:49, March 18, 2012 (UTC)


 * Shhh, I don't know this page exists (Special:WhatLinksHere/User:AEtherchild). For the record the deck runs a lot smoother with 2 Hieratic Dragon of Gebeb instead of the Dragorado and Hieratic Dragon of Nuit, a Starlight Road instead of the random Lumenize, an Enemy Controller instead of one of the Dragonic Tactics, and a Stardust Dragon instead of the 2nd Sacred Pleiades. Torrential at 2 I wasn't a fan of, as I tended to keep a very heavy field advantage after those tweaks. AEtherchild (Talk|Contribs) 18:33, March 18, 2012 (UTC)


 * Then, you should have used Mirror Force, no? Yeah. meta wise it has its disadvantages, but seeing as Dragons in general have high ATK and are hard to get over, I would have preferred Mirror Force after the edits. Your the 2nd person to find this place. -- - Dark Ace SP ( Talk )  18:44, March 18, 2012 (UTC)


 * Hmm, I might have to remove the link to the Applicant's name in the future. -- - Dark Ace SP ( Talk )  18:45, March 18, 2012 (UTC)

The deck looks pretty good, but: Elite Wolf (talk • contribs) 07:38, March 21, 2012 (UTC)
 * Gorz over the second Chaos Sorc
 * Would use a 3rd Veiler over the single Maxx "C" (seems too random, more LIGHT targets if using 2 Chaos Sorcs)
 * No Scrap Dragon
 * Needs a little more defense, mainly Torrential/Mirror Force

Random Maxx "C" can be ok, even though 2-3 is better. Triple Veiler can clog your hand and isn't worth running in 3's unless it's you're only LIGHT target for BLS. Synchro Maniac10 (talk • contribs) 20:23, March 21, 2012 (UTC)

The deck actually playtests very solidly, but I've been opening really well. There were a few games of bad hands, so there are a couple changes I would personally make to the deck. Overall, I'm happy with the deck though. My vote is for a yes, though I'd encourage him to run his decks by one of our more experienced deck builders just to get some opinions before posting. Lappyzard (talk • contribs) 19:12, March 22, 2012 (UTC)
 * The Monster count is just a bit too high for me. I would like to see the 3 Alexandrite Dragons dropped (because they don't work with Merchant), and if that feels like too few Monsters, I would add the third Garnet.
 * Another version that I would have liked to explore is using Mad Dog of Darkness and Vorse Raider along with Horn of the Phantom Beast in place of the Gem Merchants. I can see reasons why it would work and why it wouldn't, and I'm not saying it would be better or worse, just that I would personally like to explore the option.
 * Tyrant's Throes is too vulnerable to MST, even with Skill Drain and Heart drawing the fire away. I would much rather have seen the use of Heat Wave, and most likely 3 copies of it.
 * I would want to fit in a third Duality somehow. I'd also be interested in trying a third Skill Drain and/or a third Heart, but it may not be necessary, especially Heart if the Monster count is reduced.


 * So, overall vote is a Yes? -- - Dark Ace SP ( Talk )  00:11, March 23, 2012 (UTC)


 * I vote yes. Elite Wolf (talk • contribs) 00:42, March 23, 2012 (UTC)


 * 3 Yes to 0 No. I'll post up our comments. -- - Dark Ace SP ( Talk )  17:52, March 24, 2012 (UTC)

Galaxy Deck: Sacred Crane Deck: Normal Beatdown Deck:
 * Run Torrential at 2.
 * Why user Lumenize when you can use Honest?
 * The use of Dragonic Tactics was pretty interesting.
 * Missing Hieroglyph Dragon - Dragon Geib.
 * I think the idea was to tribute 2 Hieroglyph(s) with Dragonic Tactics for GEPD and 2 Seal of the God Dragon. Then it's theoretically possible to summon Neo Galaxy-Eyes Photon Dragon. However, if he really wanted that, Geib would have been perfect, he only takes up a single Normal Summon, compared to the others that need to be either Tribute Summoned or Special Summoned.
 * Gorz over the second Chaos Sorc
 * Would use a 3rd Veiler over the single Maxx "C" (seems too random, more LIGHT targets if using 2 Chaos Sorcs), however, a single "C" is sometimes fine.
 * No Scrap Dragon
 * Needs a little more defense, mainly Torrential/Mirror Force
 * The Monster count is just a bit too high for me. I would like to see the 3 Alexandrite Dragons dropped (because they don't work with Merchant), and if that feels like too few Monsters, I would add the third Garnet.
 * Another version that I would have liked to explore is using Mad Dog of Darkness and Vorse Raider along with Horn of the Phantom Beast in place of the Gem Merchants. I can see reasons why it would work and why it wouldn't, and I'm not saying it would be better or worse, just that I would personally like to explore the option.
 * Tyrant's Throes is too vulnerable to MST, even with Skill Drain and Heart drawing the fire away. I would much rather have seen the use of Heat Wave, and most likely 3 copies of it.
 * I would want to fit in a third Duality somehow. I'd also be interested in trying a third Skill Drain and/or a third Heart, but it may not be necessary, especially Heart if the Monster count is reduced.

User:Tyrantglider - Testers are SM10, Wolf, and Lappy - Trial 15
Let's get it going. Lappyzard (talk • contribs) 23:35, March 20, 2012 (UTC)

Absolutely not. Lappyzard (talk • contribs) 19:25, March 22, 2012 (UTC)


 * Fail him? I saw the decks too...50 cards for variety? No. -- - Dark Ace SP ( Talk )  00:09, March 23, 2012 (UTC)

Deck size alone makes me want to say no. I want to see how he builds the decks with 40-41 cards before I give my final decision. Elite Wolf (talk • contribs) 00:46, March 23, 2012 (UTC)