Forum:Black Garden with No Plants

a

Ok, so I saw that this question had been asked before with the answer of no you cannot use its second effect with no plants on the board.

But I would like to see if there is any actual proof of this (Like a KDE, UDE, Official judge forum post)

Just saying that the logic of "the effect not being fulfilled" is not entirely true, since are destroying a card (Black Garden) and reviving a monster (something with 0 ATK)

Here is the text so we don't have to keep jumping back and forth.

When a monster is Normal or Special Summoned, except by the effect of "Black Garden", halve its ATK and Special Summon 1 "Rose Token" (Plant-Type/DARK/Level 2/ATK 800/DEF 800) to its controller's opponent's side of the field, in Attack Position. You can destroy this card and all face-up Plant-Type monsters on the field and Special Summon 1 monster with ATK equal to the total ATK of those monsters from your Graveyard.

Thanks 24.100.25.239 12:38, 2 July 2009 (UTC)