Forum:Azure Eyes and Black Horn of Heaven

Basically, I am confused. Whilst dueling my friend, we came across an odd issue, which advice has become necessary. During the battle, I synchro summoned Azure Eyes Silver Dragon, whose effect states that dragon type monsters you currently control cannot be targeted or destroyed by card effects until the end of the next turn. Destroyed means to be sent to the graveyard, and keeping that in mind I felt confident in the summon. Now here is where things broke out into chaos. He flipped Black Horn of Heaven, and said that Azure Eyes was simply destroyed. I was furious. Black horn of heaven states that when your opponent would special summon a monster: negate the special summon, and if you do, destroy it. Then I thought for a moment after I raged, and realized that Azure Eyes cannot be destroyed by card effects. I argued my point, but he stood firm by his decision that he was correct. I understand that Black Horn of Heaven is spell speed 3, but once I had Azure Eyes on the field his effect comes into play. My friend says that black horn of heaven negates his effect, rendering him weak against Black Horn of heaven. This although, does not make since, because Black Horn of Heaven does not say "it negates the effect of the monster, and then negates the special summon." I guess what I'm trying to say is I need a ruling on this card effect, for this is a severe pain to me, and is giving me a rash. Please help, and thank you. Admin advice would be great!

---AzureEyeswtw