Forum:Swap frog + frog N Summon

I recently had a judge rule something in a game that I disagree with. I would like to explain the ruling and hear opinions. I will only list cards important.

My opponent has Swap Frog and a Monarchs in their hand. The also have a Frogs monster in the graveyard. My opponent Normal Summoned Swap Frog and used its effect to send Ronintoadin from the deck to the graveyard. My opponent removes the Frog in the graveyard and Special Summons Ronintoadin. My opponent Bounced Swap Frog and Normal Summoned the Monarch using Ronintoadin as Tribute Material.

I said that because Swap Frog was Normal Summoned before the bounced card to activate the effect, it cannot be called the "Frog" that my opponent could Normal Summon in addition to the 1 Normal Summon or Set per turn. As such, my opponent cannot Normal Summon the Monarch. The judge disagreed. Am I wrong with this? -- LordGeovanni - ( Talk To Me ) *Kupo* 01:18, September 17, 2010 (UTC)