Forum:Volcanic Counter vs. Multiple Copies

Hello.

I'm wondering, out of the two scenarios below, which one Volcanic Counter would work in.

Scenario A: --I have 3x Volcanic Counter in my Graveyard, no other FIRE-Attribute monsters. --I am about to take 2000 LP battle damage.

1.) I would take the damage (8000 LP -> 6000 LP). 2.) All three Volcanic Counters would attempt to activate at the same time, and form a chain. 3.) Volcanic Counter C would activate (since chains resolve backwards), and since Volcanic Counters B and A still exist in my Graveyard, the opponent would take the same amount of battle damage. (Opponent: 8000 LP -> 6000 LP.) 4.) Volcanic Counter B would activate, and since Volcanic Counter A still exists in my Graveyard, the opponent again takes the amount of battle damage (Opponent: 6000 LP -> 4000 LP.) 5.) Volcanic Counter A would attempt to activate, but since no FIRE-Attribute monster exists in my Graveyard, it is removed from play without damage. 6.) The turn ends.

Scenario B: --I have 3x Volcanic Counter in my Graveyard, and 1x Lonefire Blossom. --I am about to take 2000 LP battle damage.

1.) I would take the damage (8000 LP -> 6000 LP). 2.) All three Volcanic Counters would activate at once, not forming a chain. 3.) The three Volcanic Counters are removed from play, all at the same time, each dealing 2000 LP damage to my opponent. (Opponent: 8000 LP -> 6000 LP -> 4000 LP -> 2000 LP.) 4.) The turn ends.

If neither scenario is correct, please give me a correct one.

Thank you.

69.250.155.239 (talk) 23:04, February 23, 2011 (UTC)