Forum:Again with damn book of moon

okay iv been a long time player to this game and when some of the older cards get popular alot of ppl seem to rethink on how they work and its been really pissing me off, okay on to the supject at hand i came across a big gamer site that keeps track of top 8 n what not and they seem to have alot of ppl on there site too, ppl that are as confusing as hell the main thing that got me was a top 10 list of defensive cards and book of moon was one of them but they some how came up with these rulings for it

[A monster whose battle position has been changed by "Book Of Moon" cannot have its battle position "manually" changed again in the same turn. [UDE Netrep File]

When "Book Of Moon" is activated on an attacking monster, the attack will stop. No replay will be triggered because the number of monsters on your opponent's side of the field has not changed. The selected monster's battle position may not be changed during the main phase 2. [UDE Netrep File]

VS. "Snatch Steal": If "Book Of Moon" is activated on a creature stolen with "Snatch Steal", "Snatch Steal" will be destroyed, but the monster will remain where it is due to the "reset" when it is dflipped face down. [UDE Netrep File]

VS. "Spirit Reaper": When "Book Of Moon" is activated on "Spirit Reaper", "Spirit Reaper" will not be destroyed. "Spirit Reaper" will activate once "Book Of Moon" resolves, however, it will be face down, therefore, without effect. [UDE Netrep File]

not i dont know if there just cuting parts of the rulings out or if they think thats it but what i want to know for sure if a said monster of any kind that was NOT summoned/set and did NOT manually had is battle position changed that turn why in all of the world would u not be able to manually change is battle position and filp summon it back on the same turn (as we have been able to do since the card came out) >.< and for those of you that wish to check out the website http://yugioh.tcgplayer.com/ theres the url and http://yugioh.tcgplayer.com/db/article.asp?id=2305 on that page is where they posted thses so called rulings >.> someone out there please tell me this is wrong and as long as this said monster didnt have any of the above done that turn that u can still very much so filp it back up!!!! <.< if not was dosnt book of moon just say Flip 1 face-up monster on the field into face-down Defense Position untill i feel like its ok for u to filp it back up (maybe next turn...if ur lucky ) 71.115.110.172 04:18, September 13, 2009 (UTC)