Forum:Another arguement with Dark Creator

Everyone I play seems to wanna bitch at me about Dark Creator. If you saw my other thread about someone claiming you couldn't use DDR on a Dark Creator even if you had succesfully summoned one well this is a different problem

I was playing a game were I had sent 1 dark creator to the graveyard by the effect of a Trade In. Several turns later when my graveyard and field were setup for a second dark creator I summoned my second one. After I did this I went about removing from play one dark monster from my graveyard to special summon the other dark creator I had in the graveyard. My oppenent cried bloody murder claiming I couldn't due that. That Dark Creator could only be summoned by his own inherent effect and that yes if I had succesfully summoned a Dark Creator that I could specail summon another but only if the I had control of no monsters on the field.

I knew of his summoning condition but had thought that for semi-nomi monsters that after you had special summoned them correctly the first time that unless the monster had been bounced back to the hand or deck or negated outright that all summoning conditions were removed including this particular one.

Can someone please direct me to a place were I could find concrete evidence that either tells me that I was in the right and had played a legal move or if it is a illegal move and that I shouldn't ever do it again.

BTW if you wanted to know I let the baby have his way and instead went with Red Eyes Darkness Metal followed by Dark Horus and killed him anywaySteelfallenangel 20:43, October 7, 2009 (UTC)